MeeBlip

The hackable digital synth

It has been two hectic months since we announced the MeeBlip project.  We hoped to sell around 100 synths by Christmas, but things didn’t quite work out that way — we received over 100 orders in the first 48 hours alone. So far, we’ve sold and shipped over 250 instruments to 17 different countries. MeeBlip has been an amazing success, and we’ve learned a few things worth sharing in the process.

1. It’s really hard to estimate sales for open source projects

Peter and I literally had no idea how many synths we were going to sell. We agreed that it shouldn’t be too hard to sell a production run of 100, and guessed that perhaps half of you would choose the DIY version, while the other half would opt for the cased Quick Build kit.

We surpassed our sales estimate after only a couple of days, and the DIY kit accounted for a mere 25% of sales. That meant that we sold out of cases almost instantly and had to wait weeks for new cases to be machined and delivered by the manufacturer.

2. Doing stuff by hand is really slow

Well, we knew that going in.

But remember we thought we’d receive only a handful of orders each day, so it seemed reasonable to solder them by hand — a process that takes about an hour. Unfortunately, that approach falls apart when you surpass more than one or two units per day.

The solution was to order a batch of pre-assembled boards from the circuit board manufacturer. It took longer than we hoped because the through-hole parts that make MeeBlip DIY-friendly require a lot of hand assembly.  It took a few weeks of careful scheduling and back and forth, but they really saved our bacon.

3. Micro manufacturing is expensive

There’s a reason why many DIY projects are sold as bare boards. By the time we had paid programming and setup fees, each MeeBlip case cost well over $20. The (really nice) top and rear overlays cost almost as much, which really pushed up prices

Many people have requested complete kits that include the case, overlays, circuit board and unassembled parts, expecting to save a lot by putting it together themselves. However, the reality of manufacturing in small batches is that most of the cost is in the components and design until you start making thousands of units per run.

Assembly costs are only about $8 per unit, which makes it pretty hard to entice people to build it themselves.

4. Open source hardware is about making the future cooler

While open source hardware isn’t a great way to get rich in a hurry (I’d recommend investment banking), nothing beats the feeling of exhilaration when people start emailing sound samples, photos of their custom cases (like Michael Roebbeling’s brilliant design, above) and details of their own versions with homebuilt circuit boards.

I’ve heard from a number of people who have clever software ideas they’re anxious to try or who are interested in integrating elements of MeeBlip into their own designs. That’s what open source hardware is all about — sharing knowledge to make cooler stuff.

Thanks for allowing Peter and I to share the MeeBlip adventure with you. We’ve got some cool updates coming soon.

17 Responses

  1. Levi

    I'm stoked to receive it. I sorta wish I had gotten the DIY kit, but I perhaps will order a board and chip and build a custom, second meeblip. Perhaps I will simply take apart the one I get and make a case anyhow. I was getting antsy when I got an email saying they would be shipped later than the estimate I was first given (the end of November), but I think it will be worth the wait.

  2. Nick

    Make your life easier and charge 200% more for assembled units. Let the laws of supply and demand work their magic. Why charge only $50 for the labour of assembly? Make the price difference between the assembled unit and the kit much larger.

    Most of the people not buying the kit version probably don't care it is open source. They just see a cool, unique hardware synth under $150 and they want it.

  3. James Grahame

    Actually, the $50 price difference between the hacker board and the pre-built board/case version goes towards parts.

    No one ever seems to talk about this stuff, but I will. The cases cost $22, the overlays $10.94 and assembly was about $8, plus shipping. That's an additional parts cost of $40.94 per unit.

    My main frustration was with the case manufacturer. They were charging us about 50% more to buy the cases direct than we could get them for through Digikey. When I asked them to match the price, they said, "Digikey is a big customer, so they get better prices."

    My response was to order the subsequent batch of cases from Digikey and contract a local machinist to do the CNC work. It'll be less expensive in the long run, and working with a local guy is much easier (no shipping, no scheduling uncertainty). So, the MeeBlip project wins, the local machinist wins, Digikey wins… and the manufacturer loses. :)

  4. Peter Kirn

    @Nick: I just want to chime in to say that I don't see pricing and whether or not it's open source as being related. (Maybe in some sense that's what you're saying, as well..)

    I do think people will care it's open source, if all goes according to plan and we make some use of that over 2011. ;)

    Anyway, that's a separate discussion. We're not jacking up prices of assembled kits because we very much want people to buy assembled kits. The ready-made case is a huge convenience, it makes the whole thing far more road-worthy than most DIY cases are likely to be (unless you really know what you're doing), and it frees up time to focus on using the synth for music. Obviously, having the DIY kit as an option is important, too, or we wouldn't have done it. But I think both James and I wanted to make sure price wouldn't be an obstacle for those who wanted the quick-build kit, so that people can choose the solution that's best for them.

    Anyway, we can get to all the other stages of this now as these things get into people's hands. And I think we've learned our lesson with the Canadian Post!

  5. Nick

    @Peter and James,

    Thanks for the feedback, and congrats on the project. Are you guys going be be at NAMM?

  6. James Grahame

    Neither of us will be at NAMM this year, unfortunately.

  7. Julien Bayle

    NICE !

    Actually (and finally) designing my sound machine, you're just … inspiring !!
    :)

    finally and unfortunately, no protodeck v2.0 and commercial version :-(

  8. Peter Kirn

    We'll just have to throw our own party.

    International Association of MeeBlip Makers?

    IAMM!

  9. funnelbc

    Got mine yesterday! Put it together over breakfast and I can't wait to have a fiddle on the weekend! :D

  10. nick

    you guys rock! i'm loving my meeblip. it has ousted my analog synth for my basslines because of it's unruly character. i've been working on some chiptunes for a videogame project and the meeblip is dominating them!!

    i've started a little project making drum sounds with the meeblip too. it's tough but worth it >:-)

  11. Talon

    Really can't wait to receive mine although it's taking very long for some reason (nearly a month).

    I'm sure it will be worth it!

  12. Andrew O'Malley

    Great read about your progress w/ this!

  13. batman52

    Why you still don't ship the hacker kit WITH the case? I would have spent the same money of the pre-built kit for that, but because of the offer on the hacker of these days, I bought the hacker instead (and now i am a little bit regretting because, while I do have soldering skills I am not sure I am good enough to build a decent case). Moreover: could you please make public the dimensions of the case you are using (=link to the specifications from the manufacturer)? And the holes+dimensions of the rear panel?

    Thank you in advance

  14. James Grahame

    We had a number of requests from people for a full kit including the case.

    As I mentioned above, each case + overlays costs us about $41. Plus the power supply and I/O daughterboard. Plus credit card fees (about 3% of the total transaction).

    We're selling the case parts at very low markup. We offered people the full kit for $119, but only two were interested in purchasing it. The rest were hoping for something a lot cheaper.

  15. batman52

    I forgot… the fact that shipping with the case was more expensive than the kit was decisive in the chose for the hacker kit.

  16. batman52

    But still I am gonna pay something like 30€ for a generic case that I will need to fit myself to the meeblip.

    As a side note… if you ever plan to build a meeblip2.0, I strongly advise you to choose a more powerful chip: you see that in the total manufacturing cost is not that relevant, and with a 16bit core clocked at a few hundred of MHz, it should be pretty easy to have a decent polyphonic virtual analog synth… I would be really happy to see it :-)

    Keep your good job!

  17. James Grahame

    Yeah, the cased version weighs about 600g. Canada Post charges a phenomenal $33 to ship it to Europe. We're going to start shipping from the USA, which should cut costs in half and speed up shipping.

    As far as next-generation chips go, I really like the Microchip dsPIC line. They're inexpensive, simple and have a DSP core which would make life much easier.

Leave a Reply